Looking for something a bit different than Agreeable Gray?

I get it. Everyone and their neighbor seems to have Agreeable Gray on their walls these days. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a great color. But maybe you’re craving something with a little more personality?

Well, you’re in luck! Benjamin Moore offers fantastic alternatives, such as Collingwood, that provide a perfect neutral vibe with a unique twist.

Let me show you some colors that are just as lovely but won’t make your guests think they’ve walked into another cookie-cutter home.

Ready to find your new favorite gray?

Why Are People Stepping Away from Agreeable Gray

Agreeable Gray fatigue is real, and I’m seeing it everywhere! After years of being the go-to neutral, people are craving something fresh. It’s become so common that walking into yet another Agreeable Gray room feels a bit predictable.

I think we’re all just ready for more personality in our spaces. Sure, it’s safe and works with everything, but sometimes safety can get boring. People want colors that feel more “them” and less like everyone else’s Pinterest board.

Plus, with so many gorgeous alternatives available, why stick with what everyone else is doing? It’s time to branch out!

Agreeable Gray Alternatives from Benjamin Moore Paint

Ready to step outside the Agreeable Gray box?  

These shades are some of the most popular Benjamin Moore gray paints, ranked by designers, and are having their moment right now.

Each one brings something special to the table while keeping that perfect neutral balance we all crave.

1. Collingwood (OC-28) This gorgeous greige is like Agreeable Gray’s cooler, more refined sibling. I used this in my cousin’s master bath, and oh my god – it was stunning. It has beautiful blue-gray undertones that give rooms a calming feel without being too cold.

2. Classic Gray (OC-23) This one’s like Agreeable Gray’s slightly more classy cousin. It has a touch more depth and richness that makes rooms feel cozy without being dark.

3. Balboa Mist (OC-27) This color feels like a gentle, warm hug. It has soft beige undertones that make spaces feel incredibly welcoming and lived-in.

4. Revere Pewter (HC-172) The perfect middle ground between gray and greige. This color has just enough warmth to feel inviting but stays neutral enough to work anywhere.

5. Stonington Gray (HC-170) A bit cooler than Agreeable Gray, this one brings a fresh, clean feeling to any room. It’s perfect if you want something crisp but not stark.

6. Gray Owl (OC-52) This beauty has subtle blue undertones that give it a serene, spa-like quality. It’s calming without being boring.

How to Find the Perfect Alternative

Choosing the right paint color can feel overwhelming, but I’ve got some tried-and-true tricks that’ll make the process so much easier.

These tips will help you find a color that you’ll love for years to come, not just for the next few months. Here’s what I always tell people when they’re hunting for their perfect neutral:

• Test in different lights: The paint appears completely different in morning light versus evening light. I always recommend getting samples and watching how they change throughout the day.
• Consider your existing elements: Look at your flooring, furniture, and fixtures. Your new color should complement what you already have, not fight with it.
• Think about the room’s purpose: A bedroom might call for something warmer and cozier, while a home office might benefit from something crisp and energizing.
• Don’t forget about undertones: Every “neutral” has hidden colors lurking beneath the surface. Some lean warm, others cool. Make sure you’re happy with what you see.
• Start small: If you’re nervous about committing, try your chosen color in a powder room or closet first. It’s like a paint test drive!

Conclusion

So there you have it!

While Agreeable Gray will always have its place in the paint hall of fame, these Benjamin Moore alternatives prove there’s a whole world of beautiful neutrals waiting for you.

Each one brings its own special something to your space. The key is finding the one that speaks to your style and makes you smile every time you walk into the room.

Don’t be afraid to step outside your comfort zone; sometimes the most rewarding choices are the ones that feel a little different.