Gray cabinets got you feeling indecisive? Trust me, I get it.

You’re standing in the paint aisle, holding two gray samples that look almost identical. But the thing is, they’re not. Agreeable Gray cabinets whisper cozy farmhouse, while Anew Gray cabinets shout modern chic.

One feels warm. The other stays cool. And honestly? Your kitchen’s personality depends on which team you pick.

So let me save you some sanity and help you figure out which gray will make your cabinets sing.

Is Gray a Good Choice for Your Cabinets?

Gray cabinets are having a serious moment, and honestly? They deserve it.

Gray works because it’s the perfect middle child. Not too bold like navy, not too safe like white. It gives you that modern vibe without making your kitchen look like a sterile hospital.

Plus, gray cabinets hide fingerprints way better than white ones do.

It doesn’t matter if selling tomorrow or staying forever, gray cabinets won’t make buyers run screaming. They’re timeless enough to last but fresh enough to feel current.

Comparison Between Agreeable Gray vs Anew Gray

Let me break down these two paint superstars for you. Both are gray cabinet favorites, but they couldn’t be more different in personality.

One brings warmth like your favorite sweater, the other delivers cool confidence like a fresh morning breeze. Here’s everything you need to know about these color champions.

Agreeable Gray

This beige-gray hybrid brings warmth to any cabinet space.

Key Stats:

• LRV: 60 (reflects good light)
• Undertones: Beige and greige
• Personality: Cozy and inviting
• Best with: Warm metals like brass and gold

Anew Gray

It keeps things crisp and clean. Anew Gray works well with cool-toned woods like honey oak cabinets.

Key Stats:

• LRV: 58 (slightly less reflective)
• Undertones: Blue and green hints
• Personality: Fresh and modern
• Best with: Cool metals like chrome and nickel

Similarities Between Both Colors

Both colors play nicely with others. They’re:

• Light enough to brighten your kitchen
• Neutral enough for any style
• Popular enough to find matching decor easily

Key Differences Between the Two

Here’s how they stack up side by side:

Both colors are crowd-pleasers, but this table shows exactly where they part ways. Your choice really comes down to whether you want your kitchen to feel like a warm hug or a fresh breeze.

Factors to Consider Before Making a Choice

Here’s what you need to think about before committing to your gray:

Your Kitchen’s Natural Light

North-facing kitchens love Agreeable Gray’s warmth. It fights off that cold, cave-like feeling. South-facing spaces can handle Anew Gray’s coolness without looking harsh.

Your Home’s Style

Farmhouse and traditional styles? Go with Agreeable Gray. It plays perfectly with wood tones and vintage vibes. Modern and contemporary kitchens sing with Anew Gray’s clean lines.

Your Existing Fixtures

Got warm brass hardware? Agreeable Gray is your friend. Cool chrome and stainless steel? Anew Gray won’t clash with your existing metals.

Your Personal Preference

Some people are warm-toned souls, others are cool-toned creatures. Trust your gut. You’ll be looking at these cabinets every morning with your coffee.

Resale Value Considerations

Both colors are safe bets for resale. But if you’re in a trendy area that loves modern design, Anew Gray might have a slight edge. Traditional neighborhoods often prefer Agreeable Gray’s warmth.

Conclusion

Both colors are winners in their own right.

Agreeable Gray brings cozy warmth that makes kitchens feel like home. Anew Gray delivers crisp modernity that keeps things fresh and clean.

Consider your lighting, your style, and what makes you smile when you walk into your kitchen. Because at the end of the day, you’re the one who has to live with these cabinets.

Still feeling stuck? Grab samples of both and live with them for a week.

See which one feels right when you’re making your morning coffee or cooking dinner.