Standing in the paint aisle, squinting at fifty shades of “not quite white, not quite gray” colors that all look identical under those harsh store lights.
A few months back, I was confused between two heavy hitters: Revere Pewter and Anew Gray. Both promise that perfect greige magic we’re all chasing. The thing is, one of them might turn your cozy living room into a sad, cold cave.
Let me help you pick the winner before you make a costly mistake.
Why Is Greige All the Rage Right Now
Greige has taken over our homes. I spent so much time staring at my Anew Gray cabinets, and honestly, I’m not complaining. This gray-beige hybrid gives us the best of both worlds without committing to stark gray or boring beige.
Here’s why everyone’s obsessed with greige right now:
- It works with literally everything (your grandma’s antique chair and your modern sofa? Perfect match)
- Makes small spaces look bigger without feeling cold
- Plays well with both warm and cool accent colors
- Never goes out of style like that trendy teal you regretted last year
- Hides dirt better than pure white (thank you, messy kids and pets!)
Greige is basically the Switzerland of paint colors. Neutral, reliable, and somehow makes everyone happy.
Revere Pewter vs Anew Gray
Time for the main event! Let’s meet our two contenders. Both are gorgeous and popular, but they’re definitely not the same color, even when wearing different name tags.
Revere Pewter
This Benjamin Moore favorite has been winning hearts forever. With its Light Reflectance Value (LRV) of 55.51, Revere Pewter brings enough brightness to keep rooms from feeling gloomy.
The undertones? That’s where things get interesting; it leans toward warm beige with just a whisper of green. Think of it as the cozy sweater of paint colors.
Anew Gray
Sherwin-Williams’ Anew Gray comes in with an LRV of 58, making it slightly brighter than Revere Pewter. Its undertones play more toward the gray side with subtle blue hints.
This one’s like that friend who’s always put-together but still approachable. Cool, calm, and collected.
Anew Gray is one of the best choices for cabinets, closets, etc. I used Anew Gray with honey oak cabinets in my sister’s home, and WOW. It truly is a match made in heaven.
Similarities Between the Two Colors
Both colors are like distant cousins at a family reunion, related but with their own quirks. Here’s what they share in common.
- Works beautifully with white trim and dark accents
- Neither one screams for attention; they’re content being the perfect backdrop
- Both have enough depth to avoid looking flat or boring
- Play nice with natural wood tones
- Handle different lighting conditions pretty well
- Won’t clash with your existing furniture (unless it’s neon pink, but that’s a whole other conversation)
These two get along so well, you could probably use them in adjacent rooms without anyone noticing the switch.
Differences Between the Two Colors
Let me break it down in a way that actually makes sense.
While both colors might seem similar at first glance, their personalities become clear once you see them in action. Here’s how they stack up against each other:
| Aspect | Revere Pewter | Anew Gray |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Undertone | Warm beige with green hints | Cool gray with blue hints |
| LRV | 55.51 | 58 |
| Warmth Level | Warmer | Cooler |
| Best Lighting | North-facing rooms | South-facing rooms |
| Mood | Cozy and welcoming | Fresh and clean |
| Pairs Best With | Warm whites, cream trim | Cool whites, crisp trim |
| Popular Use | Living rooms, bedrooms | Kitchens, bathrooms |
The differences might seem small on paper, but trust me, your walls will tell a completely different story depending on which one you choose.
Which One to Go For
Still can’t decide? Let me help you figure this out without flipping a coin.
Choose Revere Pewter if:
- Your home gets limited natural light
- You love cozy, warm spaces
- You have warm wood tones or brass fixtures
- You want something that feels like a hug
Choose Anew Gray if:
- Your rooms get lots of natural light
- You prefer crisp, clean vibes
- You have cool-toned fixtures and furniture
- You want something fresh and modern
When in doubt, get samples and live with them for a week. Paint changes throughout the day, and what looks perfect at noon might feel totally different at sunset.
Conclusion
So there you have it, the great greige showdown!
Both Revere Pewter and Anew Gray are solid choices that’ll make your walls look good and your guests jealous.
The real winner? Whichever one makes you smile when you walk into the room. Because at the end of the day, you’re the one living with it.
And if you still can’t choose? There’s always the flip-a-coin method. Sometimes the best decisions happen when we stop overthinking and just go for it!
